This Guy Accused Me of Not Being Qualified & Calls My Workouts “Dangerous”


I recently received an email from a concerned individual who criticized my training methods and qualifications.  Here’s what the email said:

“Please stop sending me your e-mails. I find your guidelines on strength training to be potentially  dangerous and your qualifications, to give this advice, dubious.”

Huh?  I find it puzzling that he so openly criticized my training techniques even though he has never seen or done my program.  And just as crazy as that, he accused me of not qualified and dubious to be giving advice.  I mean, really?

Truthfully, I rarely get offhanded emails like this and if I do, I almost always ignore them.  But I thought I would take this opportunity to explain the basis of my MAX Workouts program, explain why it’s NOT dangerous and why it WILL help you lose weight and get lean safely.  This emailer’s grave concerns are premature and unfounded.  Hopefully this will ease his mind and reassure him that I am not endangering the lives of innocent people (sheesh!).  The advice I give is based on science, proven studies, fact-based articles and books written by qualified experts, and my two decades worth of higher education and real world experience.

The main principle on which my MAX Workouts program is based on (drumroll please)... producing power.  Power (in physics terms), is the amount of work done in a given period of time.  Work is measured by the amount of energy it takes to move a weight over a certain distance.  And so the faster you can move an object over a given distance, the more power you produce.  Since producing more power requires more energy, a workout program that is designed to maximize power will help you burn more fat and calories.  And you know that that means…more weight loss.

Power is intensity. 

This is why the workouts in the MAX Workouts program are short in duration and higher in intensity.  The more intense the effort, the more power you produce.  And since intensity is best achieved in shorter durations, the workouts are all designed around that concept.  If the duration is too long, the level of intensity decreases and you won’t be able to maximize the benefits of each workout. 

Intensity is subjective and it varies from person to person.  However, there are measurable variables that will help you objectively increase intensity.  So let’s take a look at what these variables are and how you can modify them to increase your power and intensity.

The 3 main variables are:

1. Weight
2. Speed
3. Rest Interval

Here’s how to play around with the variables to increase your intensity:

  • Increase the weight you’re using in an exercise, but try not to slow down your tempo or the rate at which you’re performing the exercise.  
  • Increase the speed at which you perform the exercise. For instance, if it takes you 30 seconds to do 10 Press Ups, try to do them in 25 seconds.  Don’t think you’ll feel the difference by subtracting just a mere 5 seconds?  Try it.  The key with speed though, is to keep good form.  Don’t cheat on the range of motion.
  • Decrease the duration of the workout or set.  This is best applied when doing a circuit training format. 
  • If you’re doing a set that involves 3 different exercises, minimize the break between exercises and try to finish the set faster than before.  Again, as mentioned above when your shortening the rest between exercises, you want to make sure that all exercises are done correctly with full range of motion and with good form

These are just some ways you can increase your intensity and power to maximize the benefits of your workout, which ultimately gets you better results faster.  

The other great thing about these kinds of workouts is that they’re scalable to fit your own level of fitness.  You can play around with all of the variables I suggested above and find the right intensity for you.  Once you’ve found it, make sure to try and keep progressing for at least 3 weeks before you change up your routine.  This should give your body enough time to get used to the exercises in the workouts and allow you to increase your intensity safely.  This is why I use a 3 week workout cycle in my MAX Workouts program—it’s just enough time to allow safe, but significant progression.  Plus, the 3 week cycle is short enough to keep your body guessing so you won’t hit a plateau.

So why did I choose power instead of endurance or strength?

Because power is the best indicator of fitness. 

If you take out skill, technique and strategies out of a sport and looked at what the best athletes have in common… it’s power

Power is the underlining constant between all of them, including pure endurance athletes.   Look at Lance Armstrong, his endurance level was measured to be no more than any of the other top cyclists, but what made him stand out was his power output!

But let’s look at you and I—regular people that want to burn fat, build lean muscle and get in shape.  Well, if you look at an athletes body, it’s no different than ours except they’re in better shape.  Physiologically their bodies work the same way.  The way they get into shape and get conditioned is no different (and should be no different) than us regular folks.   So outside of all of the sports specific skill related training they do, why should we train any differently from them?  How do professional athletes stay in shape during their off season?  It’s through the same concept that I apply in my programs.  Training to produce power is effective, efficient and results producing for all of us.  If you want to lose weight and get lean, you have to get fit.  And the better your fitness level is, the better you’re going to look.  

Potentially dangerous workouts?

The emailer had concerns about my advice being “Potentially dangerous…”  and looking back at all of the articles I’ve written, I don’t ever recall writing anything that can even remotely be construed as being dangerous.  But since it was mentioned, I figured I’ll talk about how to avoid unnecessary “danger” when you’re working out.  

First and foremost, always learn good form and technique.  I’ve posted several articles in the past on how to avoid injuries by doing exercises properly.  It may seem a little boring and repetitive, but taking time to learn proper form will help you progress much quicker in the long run.  If you’re already following my program, be sure to check out all the demo videos or step-by-step pictures of the exercises prior to starting.  Check out some tips I gave in past articles about saving your knees and lower back.  Even applying just some of these tips can help you avoid unnecessary injuries and help keep you on the right track to achieve your goals.  The takeaway point is this: never skimp on form.  When and only when you have learned proper form, should you increase your intensity.

Second, don’t lift more than you think you can. I always tell clients to check their egos at the door before they start because it’ll get in the way of a good workout.  Now, I’m not saying don’t challenge yourself.  But, you should choose a weight that’s manageable at first, then slowly progress according to your own pace.  I’m here to encourage, motivate and push you, but only you truly know your limits.  Listen to your body.

Third, since all of my workouts are based on circuit training and interval training formats, rest intervals are always suggested.  If the rest intervals are too short, make sure to increase them according to your recovery needs.

Why should anyone listen to me?

Lastly, the emailer thought my “qualifications, to give this advice, dubious…”  I’m not going to dwell on this fact because I’ve gone through too many years of university schooling and too many years of practicing and training to have to prove to this accuser (who’s never even looked at my program) whether I’m qualified to give advice or not.  My clients and readers know me better.  Yes I have a university degree (two, actually) and have had all kinds of fancy acronyms behind my name, but I’m also a big believer that credentials don’t necessarily make you credible.

That being said I want to leave you some food for thought…  

Is someone that drops out of university less qualified to build the largest most influential company in our time than someone that graduated?  Bill Gates may have something to say about that. 

If credentials determine credibility, does that mean all self made and self taught mentors are not reliable?  If so, how come so many people listen to and emulate these types of people?  Anthony Robbins is self taught and arguably the most successful self improvement coach today.  If you spent 4 years and $100,000 dollars getting some letters behind your name, you may have a different opinion of Anthony Robbins, but does it make him less qualified or reliable?     

If you don’t already know, most trainers can become certified in a weekend or by taking a test that they cram for in a few weeks just to get the letters behind their name and be “certified”.  Does that make them more qualified or reliable than someone that’s been in the field with first hand experience?  You need knowledge to apply, but without application it’s just theory. 

In the end, I believe what determines qualification and reliability isn’t the letters behind your name or what school you graduated from.  It’s results.  Results are what brings creditability.  If you can provide results for people that follow your advice or your program, then I’d say your qualified.  If you’re wondering if I’m qualified or not, “the proof is in the pudding”, as they say.  Follow MAX Workouts from start to finish and see for yourself how fast your body and mindset change.  I wouldn’t be able to promise a 60-day money back guarantee and stay in business if people weren’t getting results.  ‘Nuff said.

About The Author

Shin Ohtake is a widely recognized strength coach and fitness & fat-loss expert. His unconventional, no-nonsense approach to getting fit has made him the go-to source for fitness enthusiasts and trainers alike. Shin is also the author of the world famous, MAX Workouts book, which has transformed and reshaped the bodies of thousands of people across the globe - without requiring hours in the gym. To learn more about how MAX Workouts can help you achieve your fitness goals, visit maxworkouts.com.
Bookmark this post, or send it to a friend by clicking the "Share / Save" button below. You may also post this article to your blog or website - as long as you leave the content, links and the "About the Author" intact. Get notified of new posts by RSS or email.

Like this post? Help me spread the word!
Share/Save/Bookmark

36 Comments

Post A Comment

S.O. says: 03/16 11:41 PM

Don’t you just loooove people like that?  They just have to have an opinion even though they’ve never seen or tried your stuff.  What a #*!?* 

Here’s the thing though:  you are the most OVERQUALIFIED trainer in the field.  This guy is the one who is making “dubious” remarks, only making himself look stupid.

PS - I bet that picture is what he really looks like

S.O. says: 03/16 11:46 PM

I also wanted to say something in regards to the “dangerous” remark that guy made:

If you want to do something really dangerous, try sitting at your computer desk all hunched over….or don’t leave your house for that matter. 

Seriously, this guy needs to get a clue.

marilyn chalmers says: 03/17 06:56 AM

I think it’s great you responded to that e-mail. I am sure that these short intense workouts are the way to go. I’ve been a personal trainer for years and after reading Shin’s material I am rethinking everything. After years of split day training I am now doing full body exercises…even my clients over 70 are doing them…we’ve just taken the intensity down a notch or two. I’m sold. Your explaination is right on. Thanks Shin!

Judy Nowell says: 03/17 07:46 AM

I have been using your workout for several weeks now. I love it, although some of the workouts I have not gotten up to yet. I have not had any problems so far with injury (thank goddness).
  However I was doing the dantie girlie workouts on the floor and stuff and I did receive injury from those workouts. So..I don’t care what the guy says. I’m sticking with Max Workouts.

Judy

Funky says: 03/17 08:04 AM

Don’t you just know that people making such remarks have probably never even tried your workouts & to boot they very probably do look like the guy in the photo above.

It screams jealousy to me, nothing more, nothing less.

Keep up the great work Shin…..we luv ya & we know it works too. xx

pavlos1 says: 03/17 08:24 AM

shin this moron obviously doesnot know a workout when he sees it.hey if you dont like it dont do it.your kind is not wanted or needed.i will continue to workout with and support you shin.pavlos1

Ian says: 03/17 09:09 AM

Quite amusing! Shin, obviously you receive so little criticism, it just about knocks you out, when you do. Getting soooooooooooo few negative remarks is really remarkable. Congratulations! As Funky wrote: an obvious case of jealousy. And as such: a compliment.

ewell thompson says: 03/17 10:54 AM

Shin
As the the Bible says,” Do not be weary in well doing”. You know what you are here to do. Keep doing what God wants you to do,and that is helping people be what He wants them to be. I thank God that you e-mail me because you motivate me to be better each day. DO NOT STOP!
You do not know how may lives you reach.  Keep doing what you because I hope be in line when He tells you, “Well done my good and faithful servent”.

Andreas says: 03/17 11:17 AM

Shin

I’m not going to add comments about someone else’s opinion but as a beginner in high intensity training methods I’d like to say that like any other type of training if used properly it gives results with minimum risk of injury.
The big difference is the type of results and the time you need to start seeing and feeling the difference,
I’m using it for about a month or so and had no injury problem so far instead I started to fell better and my friends told me that I look better…

Matt Schifferle says: 03/17 11:36 AM

Of course what we are doing is dangerous on some level. But then again so is driving while talking on the phone and stairing atthe beautiful woman on the bus with the boy friend shaped like a truck.

There is always some danger, but it’s a hell of a lot safer than doing nothing. Plus as you said, if you know what you are doing the risk is much smaller than most other things we do on a daily basis.

Matt

kidzone says: 03/17 11:40 AM

Shin,I guess your tips are excellent!!!I am a woman and mother of 3!I am a bit overweight and though i train with 20kg to 40kg your body tells you your strength!!!!when jerking just stop the weight increase, but if one feels comfortable it gives you plenty of strength and tone!!!!!!!Fast to loose some weight plenty of vegetables less carbs I’m working on it and great ideas got from you work brilliant!!!Keep it up everybody knows he must check his health before doing ANY exercise!!!!
Million thanks for your great explained ideas!!!

Maggie says: 03/17 12:06 PM

Hey Shin, hope your well. Sheesh is right, what is he qualified in??? Cut your loses & remove him from your mailing list, he obviously only signed up in an attempt to discredit you.  No doubt he does that sort of thing to people who have real jobs, skills & qualifications, not to mention better things to do. You keep up the good work Shin.

eliesa tuiloma says: 03/17 02:09 PM

Poeple criticize because they cannot do it themselfs , thus they try convincing others that their plans or dreams are wrong , with make some people think that things are impossible but the other way around everything is possible and you got to close your ears from this negative comments and focus on what you want to acheive and become . thank you.

robert ettinger says: 03/17 02:28 PM

first of all he probably doe,s not even know what he is talking about in the first place. i personally practice alot of old shaolin kung-fu training techniques and some are risky,but how can you get better if you don,t try?

John says: 03/17 05:53 PM

That guy said your guidelines are “potentially dangerous” jaja… People like him are just like we say in Colombia ( AMARGADO )

Marty Martin says: 03/17 08:46 PM

Then there are just some who are assholes

Larry Edwards says: 03/18 08:52 AM

Keep up the good work. Im using the program and have had good success.

Im a fitness coordinator and have done the research as well. Im always looking for new idea and methods because this is a science and things are very fluid when it come to health & fitness.

All I can say about his comments, “this program isn’t for you. Find out what work for you and go with it. But after you get tired of not seeing quality results, then we will help you get back on the yellow brick road. Good luck”.

Keep up the good work buddy because your on target with the information that your providing.

Don says: 03/18 05:54 PM

I am 42 years old, at the ripe old age of 37 I had a 6 day vacation in the Cardiac Ward at my local hospital for a Quadruple bypass operation. After 3 months of recovery at home I was invited to take a Cardiac rehab program, hours and hours of light intensity cardio, and hours of courses on low fat dieting and cooking. I lost a ton of weight, and gained most of it back, and lost, and gained. I just don’t have all that time, or energy for low intensity work outs. I have been taking your advice for 4 weeks now and I’m starting to gain weight, but its muscle I’m gaining and I’m starting to see results. No doctor has ever helped me get into shape, all they want is to prescribe more drugs, with all their dangerous side effects. Keep on keeping on

Don

dorreenabad says: 03/18 07:08 PM

Hi Shin,
I just wanted to tell people who might not know you that trainers who are at the top of the industry that train pro athletes her in Los Angeles look to you for advise.  That says A Lot!!!!!  You train everyone from Pro Athletes to Moms ( who look like athletes because of you).  I have been training with you for a couple of years now and never have been injured from one of your workouts. If this person spent anytime with you they take all that stupid stuff said back. Keep that great workouts coming!!!!!
Dorreen

Avi says: 03/18 08:11 PM

Hi Shin,
Firstly if it’s the picture of the person you sent you the negative remarks than for sure he looks like a mental case. I wonder whats’s wrong with this junkie. May god bless this poor creature.
And as for your program Shin, to be honest I have never looked back since joining your program or have subscribed to another fitness program. Your program is the best with no bogus material and dummy excercises.Each excercise is better than the other.
You keep up the good work Shin as you might not be aware how many people’s life you have changed with your fantastic program and approach.
With Regards’
Avi.

Dorreen Abad says: 03/18 10:22 PM

Hi Shin,  I should of did a spell check before I posted.  I was typing in the dark. So here it is with correct spelling.
I just wanted to tell people who might not know you that trainers who are at the top of the industry that train pro athletes here in Los Angeles look to you(Shin) for advise.  That says A Lot!!!!!  You train everyone from Pro Athletes to Moms ( who look like athletes because of you).  I have been training with you for a couple years now and never have been injured from one of your workouts. Keep the great workouts coming!!!!!
Dorreen

dcurtis says: 03/20 09:27 PM

Shin, I love your workouts.  I just completed my second week.  The effectiveness is obvious from the beginning.  The proof is definitely in the pudding.  Thank you for sharing your inCREDIBLE program.

Dave

Michael Demler says: 03/22 09:34 AM

cool mad This guy must be an AIG employee, he wants alot for doing (and knowing) absolutely nothing.

Shin Ohtake says: 03/22 09:54 AM

Hey Everyone,

Just wanted thank you for all your positive comments!
I really appreciate all of your support.

You guys are the best!

grin

Dawn Clark says: 03/22 11:44 AM

Hi Shin,
Many of my clients who are middle aged have not moved quickly in years are initially afraid of speed in movement and have to be assured that the increase in speed will not cause injury, but once they get over the fear they are all very happy and successful with the change.  And they all like a shorter workout that still gives them the results they are getting.  Thanks for this website.

warren Canzio says: 03/23 02:28 PM

Hi Shin,
  I don’t think the guy is interested in working out, or getting into shape. So any excuse is a good excuse when you don’t want to improve yourself.
  You provide a valuable service and you are an inspiration to all of us who should be working out a little harder, in life and in the gym.

thanks,
Warren Canzio

herbalife says: 03/25 05:35 AM

If I exercise but stay with my eating habbits will I lose weight ?

Kevin from HomeGymAdviser.com says: 03/29 11:26 AM

You are absolutely correct about working out more in less time. It’s a great way to create muscle confusion and changing your routine. You can add to the load, take a breather for 20 seconds between sets, do do four sets per muscle group without stopping.

fitness activities says: 05/10 11:44 PM

Hi,
  Many women really want to get into shape but, unfortunately, they believe the several myths surrounding women’s fitness—especially when it comes weight lifting and strength training. This holds them back from getting the results they want. Here’s a great article that dispels the most common women’s fitness myths and shows you exactly how to train for the lean, fit look that you want…
fitness activities

Burnsville Personal Trainer says: 06/03 06:36 PM

It’s a saying that you cannot please everyone. For me, your work id great and just go on with it. I know more people knew that.

Best,

Rob Smith

Kenny says: 06/08 11:00 AM

grin Every high tree should expect to catch a bit of wind sometime. this is your wind which proofs that you have arrived in the land of the Big ones.  I am just glad that you responded so well to the fool’s comment. Even in your response, your usual professionalism and gentleness (the characteristics that makes you sooo!!! credible) shines through. Keep it up, your programs and advice help a great deal and many people in the strangest places on the globe

dinara says: 07/20 05:07 AM

I am here for the first time and like what and how you write. Hope to hear from you soon and something new )

NA says: 07/29 10:21 AM

The person who has written you this mail, must be like me! i hate exercises, and when they are pressed upon me i try to find such excuses.. so i would suggest you to continue with the great work you are doing, and dont get hassled by such mails

NA says: 07/30 05:21 AM

I found your blog on Google and read a few of your other posts. I just added you to my Google News Reader. Keep up the good work. Look forward to reading more from you in the future. Thanks for the informatics post.

Anonymous says: 07/30 11:50 PM

I found your blog on Google and read a few of your other posts. I just added you to my Google News Reader. Keep up the good work. Look forward to reading more from you in the future. Thanks for the informatics post.

joelw41 says: 10/18 09:06 AM

Hey Shin,
I have been doing the max workout program for about 9 months now and dont think ill ever go back to the traditional weight lifting and slow paced cardio on the treadmill. ive lost about 20 pounds since i started the program and more importantly i feel more energized and i dont have the aches and pains in my knees and shoulders. the functional strenght training is exactly what i was looking for. i wanted to comment about this clown because people in the gym are constantly asking me what im doing and “what muscle that does”. i guess what im trying to say is that a lot of these meatheads are afraid of what they dont know and theyre the one missin out. lookn forward to the next set of workouts
Joel Whaley

Page 1 of 1 pages

Post A Comment

Name:

Email:

Website:

Smileys

Comments:

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Submit the word you see below:


Fitness Tips. Delivered.

Grab A Feed

 Subscribe

Topics

Monthly Archives

Subscribe

About

My Book

Learn MoreDownload Now

follow me at http://twitter.com/ShinOhtake

Recent Entries